1984 | SCOTTISH TOUR @ ROYAL LYCEUM, EDINBURGH
★★
“A peculiarly soulless experience….”
LOVE, hate, and subjugation… 1984, George Orwell’s dystopian nightmare, loses much of its visceral impact when faced with a world in which the true horrors of population control are already insidiously and keenly honed. Unfortunately, this production remains stubbornly one-dimensional, never quite fully engaging.
Orwell wrote 1984 while dying of tuberculosis. He died seven months after completing the novel at just 46 years old. This backstory is shared in Chris Hannan’s new stage adaptation, a co-production between Glasgow’s Citizens Theatre, Edinburgh’s Royal Lyceum, and Dundee Rep.
It opens with Orwell’s Christmas Eve admission to East Kilbride’s Hairmyres Hospital – coughing up blood, yet still smoking and defiantly clinging to his portable typewriter. It was a period that would unexpectedly inform his novel and rekindle memories of being on the front line of the Spanish Civil War. Having fought alongside the socialists, communists, and anarchists, and having witnessed a ‘post-truth’ world firsthand, he had already experienced the personal threats and rewriting of history that come with a fascist playbook: the erosion of democratic norms, power grabs, and the use of violence to maintain control.



As fact and fiction mingle, it falls to Jack Tarlton to embody both Orwell and Winston Smith, the tragic anti-hero of his best-known work. A low-ranking clerk in the Ministry of Truth – where he rewrites historical documents and newspaper articles (‘Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past’) – Smith is the central focus of 1984. It’s his tale, one of love and the need for emotional and intellectual connection in the self-styled ‘utopia’ of Oceania, a totalitarian superstate existing in a state of perpetual war with an unseen enemy, Eurasia.
Tarlton fails to impress in the dual roles; both are unsympathetic creations that lack the necessary presence to hold the attention. It’s not all Tarlton’s fault, however. Hannan’s script is a dry affair that, in the hands of an uneven ensemble, becomes a blunt instrument – never as truthful as it needs to be and frequently laboured.
Consequently, the first act drags and fails to endear. Thankfully, act two fares slightly better. Cinematic-style flash cuts that move the action along are made especially effective by sound designer Mark Melville’s unsettling soundscape. Melville makes good use of composers Nikola Kodjabashia and Phineas De Thornley Head’s atmospheric compositions.
The production is also lifted by Irene Macdougall’s sinister turn as O’Brien, the conniving undercover agent of the Thought Police. It’s a highlight of the show, as is Tom Piper’s imposing industrial set design, which is enhanced by Heather Scott’s clear, impactful video messaging while Lizzie Powell’s use of colour and shade further define the playing area, all of which makes for a remarkably striking collaboration.
“Dominic Hill’s direction refuses to take risks – unfortunate, when so many opportunities are offered to do so – and the safe nature of this production, devoid of any real threat or suspense, makes for a peculiarly soulless experience.
Tickets HERE

