TO DISCUSS ADVERTISING WITH MUST SEE THEATRE, EMAIL liamruddenmedia@gmail.com
No Result
View All Result
Must See Theatre
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Features
  • Panto
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Features
  • Panto
No Result
View All Result
Must See Theatre
No Result
View All Result

Barnum Review: The Greatest Showman isn’t so great

Liam Rudden by Liam Rudden
October 12, 2026
in Theatre Reviews
0
Barnum Review: The Greatest Showman isn’t so great

BARNUM THE CIRCUS MUSICAL | UK TOUR @ FESTIVAL THEATRE, EDINBURGH

★★

“…a distinctly average example of style over substance…”

The lyrics of Join The Circus, arguably the best known number from the musical Barnum, may well encourage you to ‘join the circus like you wanted to when you were a kid…’ but Phineas Taylor Barnum was the grand old age of 60 before he succumbed to the lure of the circus ring.

Consequently, there’s a lot of backstory to get through before he teams up with James A Bailey to form Barnum & Bailey’s American Travelling circus and not all of it is gripping stuff.

A forerunner to The Greatest Showman, both musicals are very loosely based on the life of PT Barnum, Barnum premiered on Broadway in 1980 before taking London’s West End by storm a year later – Michael Crawford wowing in the lead role. 

With a book by Mark Bramble, lyrics by Michael Stewart, and music by Cy Coleman, this production, routinely directed by Jonathan O’Boyle, may be a beautifully dressed kaleidoscope of colours but it also manages to be an overtly worthy offering. All the dangerous, anarchic energy of sideshow and circus worlds stripped away to be replaced by Ote Mabuse’s well-drilled, marching band-esque choreography – with a cast of actor/musicians there’s a limit to what she can achieve due to the incumbency of the instruments.

Which is a shame, because in many ways, Barnum is a musical that lends itself to a troupe of actor/musicians better than most. Indeed, it’s the ensemble that provides the colour and fun of the piece. Elsewhere, the basic circus skills on show throughout the piece are never quite as thrilling as they could be – even Barnum’s high-wire act is unremarkable in its ambition when compared with the exploits of previous actors in the role; Peter Duncan famously zip-lining from ‘The Gods’ onto the stage to make his big entrance when he played the role three decades ago was real circus.

In the title role this time is a conversational Matt Rawle who carries the show in a likeable turn that boasts just enough compromising smarm, along with Monique Young, Barnum’s feisty and forgiving wife, Charity. If Rawle’s interpretation of the showman come hoaxer is that of ‘snake oil salesman’, hers is of a woman well aware of his penchant for ‘humbug’ (untruths).

That humbug includes the fantastical acts brought in to headline his sideshow; the 161 year old woman, who bounced George Washington on her knee wasn’t and didn’t; General Tom Thumb was never in the military; and a real life Mermaid… well.

As Joyce Heath, the aged nanny, Dominique Planter demonstrates fine vocals, sadly, any impact General Tom Thumb may have had is sacrificed by having Fergus Rattigan on stage from the start as part of the ensemble – although he does get one of the most striking numbers in the show.

Unfolding act by act adds to the vaudevillian feel of the piece but quickly becomes formulaic; acts linked by Mr and Mrs Barnum’s business and domestic exchanges. Musically there are some standout numbers, Bigger Isn’t Better and Come Follow The Band being two of the catchier toe-tapping numbers.

Jumbo, an imposing elephant puppet crafted by Mervyn Millar and Tracy Waller is another highlight of the piece as is Lee Newby’s set design, which is a thing of beauty; an Americana infused proscenium arch within a proscenium. That said, its dazzling magnificence is not enough to save this production from being anything more than a distinctly average case of style over substance – an exercise in humbug no less.

Full details and tickets HERE

Tags: BarnumBarnum reviewCapital TheatrescriticEdinburghLiam Ruddenmusicalmusical theatreMust See Theatrereview
Previous Post

Review: The Steamie At Edinburgh Kings Theatre Cleans Up

Next Post

It Walks Around The House At Night Review: A Chilling 5-Star Ghost Story

Next Post
It Walks Around The House At Night Review: A Chilling 5-Star Ghost Story

It Walks Around The House At Night Review: A Chilling 5-Star Ghost Story

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

No Result
View All Result

About Me

Must See Theatre

Liam Rudden

Writer | Broadcaster | Award-Winning Director

Líam Rudden is an award-winning playwright, broadcaster and commentator on the arts with more than 40 years experience working in theatre and media. For two decades he was the Entertainment and Festivals Editor of the Edinburgh Evening News. He is Artistic Director of Stageworks East West Ltd and a regular contributor to Hollywood.com and The Edinburgh Reporter.
Website https://liamrudden.com

Subscribe

https://liamrudden.substack.com/

November 2026
MTWTFSS
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30 
« Oct    
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Features
  • Panto

© 2024 Must See Theatre