TO DISCUSS ADVERTISING WITH MUST SEE THEATRE, EMAIL liamruddenmedia@gmail.com
No Result
View All Result
Must See Theatre
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Features
  • Panto
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Features
  • Panto
No Result
View All Result
Must See Theatre
No Result
View All Result

Review | Experimental kaleidoscope of styles excites but loses way in queer reimagining of Giselle

Liam Rudden by Liam Rudden
September 24, 2025
in EdFringe, Theatre Reviews
0
Review | Experimental kaleidoscope of styles excites but loses way in queer reimagining of Giselle

GISELLE: REMIX | PLEASANCE COURTYARD, EDINBURGH

★ ★ ★

“…full of heart, if over-long”

Coming of age stories, at their simplest, are origin stories. They may vary in their telling and individual detail, but ultimately most follow the same path within the world they are set. In Giselle: Remix, hope, despair, loss and redemption lead to, if not a happy ever after conclusion, a hopeful one.

Coming out tales are ten a penny these days and like all that have gone before, Jack Sears’ Giselle is a journey of self-discovery, as ‘the boy everyone loves but never falls in love with’ succumbs to his first real kiss, the beginning of his own odyssey into the dark underworld of love, broken hearts, sex and drugs scenes of the queer landscape. 

Sears looks to the classical romantic ballet Giselle, the tale of a country girl who dies of a broken heart on discovering her establishment lover is already engaged, to frame his own story of growing up ‘different’. The result is a very personal, physical, hybrid mix of cabaret, drag, dance theatre, posturing and much more, a lot of which works brilliantly, but some of which fails to land. 

The age-old art of mime drag might open the piece – a ‘rendition’ of Stormy Weather setting, but the mix of disciplines is jarring. From preshow to curtain, however, there is a darkness infused into this eclectic piece of theatre, much of which is lip-synched to a pre-recorded narration that is a mash-up of famous lines from movies, iconic gay songs and soundbites from a host of queer legends.

If this kaleidoscope of styles is excitingly experimental, it also makes for muddled storytelling and while the lip synching is well executed, it strips away the emotion from the performance, although it does add moments of comedy.

Elle Fierce, Naia Bautista, Jasiah Marshall, Spike King, Harri James Eiffert and Jack Sears

Consequently it’s only when dance and music align to ‘do the talking’ that the piece really flies – dancers Elle Fierce, Naia Bautista, Jasiah Marshall and Spike King deliver Hannah Grennel’s choreography with panache, while Harri James Eiffert’s ethereal presence mesmerises. 

Lucy Adams’ simple but brutally effective lighting design adds purpose and a sense of threat, while Rhys Cook’s sound design, if clever, is also convoluted.

Dressing the company in everything from traditional ballet stylings to thongs and even a gimp suit, Laura Rose Moran-Morris ensures her costumes fit the mood nicely whether it be sad, sensuous or sleazy.

In the lead role of ‘Giselle’, creator Jack Sears is fully invested in a story evidently close to his heart, he also plays the lighter moments well. Like many ‘passion projects’, and this piece leaves little doubt that it is one such production, indulgence crosses into overindulgence – the use of mime outstaying its welcome and the storytelling unnecessarily drawn out to the point it occasionally loses the ability to engage. 

That said, as a celebration of ‘queer culture’​, Sears has thrown everything possible at Giselle​: Remix ​t​o create a 70 minute mash-up that is certainly full of heart, if over-long.

Run Ended.

Tags: cabaretcriticdragEdFringeEdinburghGaygiselleLGBTQI+musicalmusical theatreMust See TheatrePleasance Courtyardqueerreviewtheatre
Previous Post

Review | Braveheart star Jimmy Chisholm leads cast in hilarious, thought-provoking Scottish comedy

Next Post

Three more stars return to Edinburgh’s big panto, Jack and the Beanstalk

Next Post
Three more stars return to Edinburgh’s big panto, Jack and the Beanstalk

Three more stars return to Edinburgh's big panto, Jack and the Beanstalk

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

No Result
View All Result

About Me

Must See Theatre

Liam Rudden

Writer | Broadcaster | Award-Winning Director

Líam Rudden is an award-winning playwright, broadcaster and commentator on the arts with more than 40 years experience working in theatre and media. For two decades he was the Entertainment and Festivals Editor of the Edinburgh Evening News. He is Artistic Director of Stageworks East West Ltd and a regular contributor to Hollywood.com and The Edinburgh Reporter.
Website https://liamrudden.com

Subscribe

https://liamrudden.substack.com/

October 2026
MTWTFSS
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 
« Sep    
The Edinburgh Reporter masthead with the words The Edinburgh Reporter masthead with the words The Edinburgh Reporter masthead with the words
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Features
  • Panto

© 2024 Must See Theatre